An online WFCC Meeting took part via Zoom connection on 25th October 2024, organized and executed by WFCC secretary Mohammad Alhallak. Among 35 participants there were delegates or deputies of 28 countries: Argentine, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Georgia, Germany, Great Britain, Greece, India, Israel, Italy, Japan, Latvia, Lithuania, Netherlands, Poland, Romania, Russia, Serbia, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland, and Ukraine.
The first topic to discuss and decide on was selection of the hosts for the two regular yearly events in 2025, 18th European Chess Solving Championship and 67th World Congress of Chess Composition (including 48th World Chess Solving Championship).
The only bid for ECSC 2025 came from Greece and was accepted by acclamation. The 18th ECSC will be held in University of Athens, from 25th to 27th April 2025.
During discussion about the three bids for WCCC & WCSC 2025, Honorary Member Hannu Harkola commented expressed opinion that according to the Statutes only the bids from member countries should be taken in consideration, and not the Montenegro bid. Since we have had exceptions before (Turkey ECSC 2008 and Montenegro ECSC 2014), the case was put on voting, and the bid wasn’t accepted, with 15 votes against it, 8 for, and 5 abstentions.
In the competition between two remaining candidates, Estonia (Tallinn) and Romania (Alba Iulia), the latter bid got 20 votes, and the former 7, with 1 abstention. Thus, the 67th WCCC and 48th WCSC will be held in the historical venue Alba Iulia, from 5th to 12th July 2025. It will be the first ever Congress in Romania, in the year when the Romanian Chess Federation celebrates its centenary.
Voting about FIDE World Cup and other FIDE supported projects in 2025 had three phases. At the beginning, 14 delegates expressed their opinion that we need FIDE World Cup, and 6 were against it, with 8 abstentions. Out of several options for the World Cup yearly budget (in Euros: 10000, 8000, 6000, 5000, 3000, 2000 and zero) most votes were given to: 5000 (7), 3000 (7) and 2000 (7), with 4 votes for 10000 and 3 for no budget at all. In the 2nd round, more than half of delegates (15) supported the budget of 3000 EUR, 8 delegates voted for 5000 and 3 for the middle option of 4000 EUR.
The decision to significantly reduce the FIDE World Cup budget in 2025, and to allocate remaining 7000 EUR to other FIDE related projects, opened the question of financing the demanding duties of World Cup Director. In an email exchange on the topic before the session (that engaged 12 delegates and 10 active composers), Torsten Linss generously offered to volunteer as the WC director in 2025, and this was accepted with a gratitude. All other details, including suggestion to revive the tradition of FIDE Olympic tourneys in even years, were postponed.
The last part of this online session was about the proposal Thomas Maeder made to WFCC Presidium to suspend Russia’s delegate Georgy Evseev, because of his statement about situation in Ukraine, expressed during Jurmala WCCC 2024. The request by Mr. Maeder, the transcript of the mentioned speech of Mr. Evseev, and the statement by the Presidium on the matter are presented in the Agenda. Presidium recommended Mr. Evseev to reconsider his statement and asked WCCT Committee to discuss the compatibility of Mr. Evseev as the spokesman in mew situation. No measures or sanctions in such a case have been predicted by the WFCC Statutes.
In a short speech, Mr. Evseev said his federation didn’t allow him to make any political comments on the matter. At the same time, he decided to step down from the positions of the WCCT Committee spokesman and the FIDE Album Committee member.
Marjan Kovačević suggested that in the current situation, with four WFCC member countries involved in wars, the WFCC needs to establish an Ethic Committee to work on Ethic Codex. Upon his proposal, Honorary Presidents Klaus Wenda and Harry Fouigiaxis, as well as the delegate of India Narayan Shankar Ram accepted to be the members if the working group, with Mr. Fougiaxis as the leader.
30 Member Countries took part in the WFCC online Meeting that was mostly devoted to discussion about the future WFCC events and the host of the 66th WCCC and 47th WCSC 2024.
At the beginning, the FIDE Album Committee spokesman Harry Fougiaxis announced the new title-holders in chess composition:
Grandmaster: Steffen Slumstrup Nielsen (DEN)
International Master: Karen Sumbatyan (RUS)
FIDE Masters: Sergiy Didukh (UKR), Daniel Keith (FRA), Jan Sprenger (GER), Aleksandr Stavrietsky (RUS)
Congratulations!!
These norms were fulfilled according to the results of the Section D (endgames) of the FIDE Album 2019-2021, published on 4th November.
Assembly was informed about the new sentence in the Rules for the World Solving Cup, Point 4, proposed by Roland Ott:
“Organisers should try to avoid holding their tournament on the same weekend as another WSC tournament that has already been published”.
During a short discussion, Neal Turner was against this kind of restriction for the WSC organizers, claiming it has already been rejected in Batumi, and should be rejected again. Other delegates, including Georgy Evseev, Kjell Widlert and Harry Fougiaxis, thought differently, that new formulation isn’t mandatory at all, that it’s only a good reminder. At the end, this additional sentence was accepted.
Marjan Kovačević presented the latest version of Calendar of composing tournaments, prepared and compiled by Kenneth Solja. He urged delegates to contribute to it, in order to complete the final goal, an official WFCC Calendar on the WFCC website.
The main discussion, about the situation in each country, and about the future WFCC events, took a long time and the whole Meeting lasted around two and half hours. The first ones to talk were delegates who presented bids to organize the WCCC & WCSC 2024.
Marcos Roland (the Rio de Janeiro bid) described his attempts to popularize chess composition in Rio and Brasilia trough the series of online lectures and solving competitions. He stressed the problem of presenting helpmates and selfmates to newcomers, and suggested these genres should be omitted in the competitions for beginners – a topic left for future meetings to be discussed.
Harry Fougiaxis, who offered the bid for Rhodes, informed about the Solving Cup to be simultaneously happening in several cities in Greece. He expressed opinion that tradition of ECSC, WCCC and WCSC each year shouldn’t be broken. In order to assure having hosts for ECSC, Harry suggested that some countries from the Central Europe should step forward and say they are ready to organize it. He thinks the suitable location and short weekend program would allow this competition to keep going and attract many participants.
Julia Vysotska explained she wanted to organize in Jurmala a Congress she would like: a kind of summer festival in an enjoyable and friendly atmosphere. Another important reason was to give a chance to young solvers she has been gathering during the last seven years, having in mind a lack of support from local chess federation. For the same reason, she supported organizing ECSC in easy to get destinations in Central Europe.
This long-lasting session was interrupted after speeches of some other delegates, to execute secret voting while all participants were still present. Out of 30 delegates in the Zoom Meeting 21 gave vote to Jurmala, four to Rhodes and three to Rio de Janeiro. One delegate didn’t vote and one was abstained. After adding two more votes sent by email, Jurmala convincingly won straight majority with 23 votes from 32 delegates.
With such a wide support, we will be preparing for a memorable Congress in Latvia, from 27th July to 3rd August 2024!
After the voting some delegates had to leave, while others continued the review by countries.
When it comes to difficulties chess composition faces, many delegates regretted not having better connections with their chess federations. A sense of general agreement was felt in the hopes that FIDE would accept official solving competitions in the context of the World Youth Chess Championship. Although Polish solvers have a relatively good position in their chess federation, Piotr Górski was also insisting on the same goal, as a good way to increase interest of the national chess federations.
Opinions about having both ECSC and WCSC each year were divided, with majority supporting it. As some of the reasons to keep the tradition, Harry Fougiaxis named chances to gain the highest solving norms, and possibility of having 4th solver in the ECSC team.
Marjan Kovačević thought two competitions per year increase organizing and financial burden, while the lack of interested hosts leaves WFCC no real possibility to control the standard of events. He insisted there should be a competition of at least two bids for each event.
Marko Klasinc suggested having WCSC and ECSC every second year, with additional competitions, such as Fairy solving. From his point of view, both competitions had a higher importance at the times before the World Solving Cup where solving norms could be gained now.
Other options to reduce costs of both events were mentioned too. Pavel Kamenik suggested ECSC to be organized simultaneously in several countries, while Dinu-Ioan Nicula strictly opposed this idea, putting under question the regularity of such events. From his side, Dinu-Ioan suggested reducing number of solvers in ECSC teams to three. He gladly announced the strong intention to organize WCCC 2025 in the year of centenary of Romanian chess federation.
17 delegates took part in this review by countries. Many of them shared the same list of difficulties: chess composition societies are getting older and smaller; the numbers of magazines and publications are reducing, and there is no adequate support from chess federations.
For a difference, Bjørn Enemark reported about the first youth solving championship in Dеnmark and continuation of the Thema Danicum magazine in PDF form; Shankar Ram explained Indian chess composers activities in other countries (The Problemist, Julia’s Fairies …);. Yochanan Afek told good news the Variantim has been published in both PDF and paper form, and endgame study has been flourishing in Israel (including Yehuda Hoch coming back after 25 years).
Italian composers are not many but Marco Guida reported they have regular weekly Skype meetings and prepare two magazines in PDF form: Sinfonie Scacchistiche and Best Problems. As Vidmantas Satkus explained, apart from keeping their magazine Šachmatija in both PDF and paper form, Lithuanian solvers have an excellent position. They have a separate sports organization out of the chess federation, with a direct support from their government. Romania is another example of good position in national Sport organization, thanks to personal involvement of Dinu-Ioan Nicula in national chess federation.
This Zoom Meeting was excellently organized by the secretary Mohammad Alhallak. He also replaced the UAE delegate Abdulla Ali Aal Barket in presenting optimistic plans about development of solving in the UAE, in neighboring countries and in the whole Asia.
The Zoom meeting 16.06.21 18:00 CEST was hosted by Andrey Selivanov with Harry Fougiaxis and Julia Vysotska as cohosts. Attendees were: Harry Fougiaxis, Greece -President, Klaus Wenda, Austria -Honourary President, Vidmantas Satkus, Lithuania -2nd Vice-President, Luc Palmans, Belgium -3rd Vice-President, Neal Turner, Finland -Secretary, Delegates from 18 countries and 5 more attendees.
The Zoom meeting 02.06.21 18:00 CEST was hosted by Andrey Selivanov with Harry Fougiaxis and Julia Vysotska as cohosts. Attendees were: Harry Fougiaxis, Greece -President, Klaus Wenda, Austria -Honourary President, Thomas Maeder, Switzerland -1st Vice-President, Vidmantas Satkus, Lithuania -2nd Vice-President, Luc Palmans, Belgium -3rd Vice-President, Neal Turner, Finland -Secretary, Delegates from 17 countries and 8 more attendees.
The Zoom meeting 19.05.21 18:00 CEST was hosted by Andrey Selivanov with Julia Vysotska as cohosts.
Attendees were: Harry Fougiaxis, Greece -President, Klaus Wenda, Austria -Honourary President, Thomas Maeder, Switzerland -1st Vice-President, Vidmantas Satkus, Lithuania -2nd Vice-President, Luc Palmans, Belgium -3rd Vice-President, Neal Turner, Finland -Secretary, Delegates from 18 countries and 6 more attendees.
Points from the previous meeting
Russian participation in world championship events
WCCC 2021
WCSC
Budget 2019-2020
Committee matters
WFCC web site
World Cup in Composing
Online task force
Next meeting
There was some questioning about how we should carry on with these meetings.
Mr Kovačević suggested we shouldn’t stop with online work until the Congress.
He also thought that there should be an official agenda drawn up and circulated before the meeting.
It was agreed the next meeting would be on Wednesday 2.6.21 18:00 CEST
The Zoom meeting 10.05.21 19:00 CEST was hosted by Andrey Selivanov with Harry Fougiaxis and Julia Vysotska as cohosts.
Attendees were: Harry Fougiaxis Greece -President, John Rice Great Britain -Honourary President, Thomas Maeder Switzerland -1st Vice-President, Vidmantas Satkus Lithuania -1st Vice-President, Neal Turner, Finland -Secretary, Pavel Kameník, Czech Republic -Delegate, Bjørn Enemark, Denmark -Delegate, Hannu Harkola, Finland -Delegate, Axel Gilbert, France -Delegate, David Gurgenidze, Georgia -Delegate, bernd ellinghoven, Germany -Delegate, Brian Stephenson, Great Britain -Delegate, Yochanan Afek, Israel -Delegate, Julia Vysotska, Latvia -Delegate, Abdelaziz Onkoud, Morocco -Delegate, Dinu-Ioan Nicula, Romania -Delegate, Andrey Selivanov, Russia -Delegate, Marjan Kovačević, Serbia -Delegate, Peter Gvozdják, Slovakia -Delegate, Joaquim Crusats, Spain -Delegate, Kjell Widlert, Sweden -Delegate, Valery Kopyl, Ukraine -Delegate, Zoltán Laborczi, Hungary -Delegate.
The meeting started on time with a discussion of the points raised by Marjan Kovačević…
1.1. Do we want to have these meetings regularly, at least until the next live Congress?
1.2. Logistic for the online meetings: who does what?
1.3. The rights for decision making
1.4. How to decide about the changes of Statutes if needed?
The ECSC & WCSC meetings
Summing up at the end of the meeting the President emphasised the importance for the Federation of the Congress going ahead this year.
Mr Kovačević welcomed the presence online of attendees from far afield such as Singapore and
India as well as others who wouldn’t normally attend live meetings.
The next Zoom meeting was set for Wednesday 19.5 at 18:00 CEST